Searching for the Afro-Latinx Community Identity

Zihui Lei | Mario Giraldo | California State University Northridge

Who Are Afro-Latinxs?

Afro-Latinxs are Latin Americans of African descent.

This definition seems clear and easy, however, for how long has identity been considered from the people of U.S.?

It was not until 2000 that the U.S. Census Bureau allowed people to identify themselves with more than one race/ethnicity.

Nevertheless, only 4.7% of Californians marked more than one race.

Pew Research Center reported in 2016 that only 18% of Afro-Latinxs identified their race or one of their races as black. In fact, 39% of Afro-Latinxs identified themselves as white, 24% volunteered that their race was Hispanic, and 9% identified as mixed race.

What makes it hard for Afro-Latinxs to identify themselves?

  • The U.S. Census Bureau’s classification of Hispanic identity: census survey forms have described “Hispanic” as an ethnic origin, not a race.
  • Until recently, most Latin American countries did not collect official statistics on ethnicity or race, especially from populations with African origins.
  • Unawareness of racial affirmation from families, communities, or schools.
  • The colorism system that allots privileges or disadvantages on the basis of the lightness and darkness of skin color.

"To be Afro-Latine, in America, is to feel like you don’t fit in anywhere. You’re not black enough, you’re not Puerto Rican enough. To be Afro-Latine is to be salsa and hip-hop, bachata and reggae, rice and beans and collard greens, papito and homeboy. Afro-Latine is important because we exist. It is what we are and our identities rest in reflecting on who we come from, especially in the United States, where we are never represented." -- Victor (Puerto Rican/Guatemalan)


Origins of the Mix-identity

Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade

Hierarchically Racial System

Casta painting showing 16 hierarchically arranged, mixed-race groupings, 1777

Palenque

"Palenque" is a wooden structure and walled community of only runaway enslaved Africans.

Palenque Communities in Colombia during 1500s, 1600s, and 1700s

Photographer Richard Cross captured images of living conditions in San Basilio de Palenque in 1970s. These images illustrated laborious life in San Basilio de Palenque, alongside the resilience of its residents.

Life in San Basilio de Palenque, Colombia (1975-1978)


A Journey for a New Identity


Afro-Latinx Mix-identity in 21st Century

Population of Afro-Latinx In Latin Americas

Afro-descendants in Latin America, in thousands

Population of Afro-Latinx In the U.S.

According to Pew Research Center:

In 2016, one-quarter of all U.S. Latinxs self-identify as Afro-Latinx.

65% of Afro-Latinxs are concentrated on the East Coast and in the South, while only 48% of other Latinxs live in those regions.

Currently, most recent Afro-Latinxs in the U.S. are immigrants from Latin American countries from the mid-1970s. 70% of Afro-Latinxs are foreign born, while 52% are among other Latinxs.

Living with One's Own Culture

Historical and Cultural Contributions

Afro-Latino Travels with Kim Haas is a cultural travel series that celebrates the cultural achievements of Afro-Latinxs. Kim Haas explores history, art, music, dance, cuisine education, sports, and environmental conservation that African descendants brought to Latin America.

The latest episode to Limón told historical story that Jamaicans, Afro-Latinxs, and other Caribbean islanders played in the construction of the country’s railroad more than a century ago. The railroad was used for the fruit trade, which was integral to Limon’s early economy. Cultural stories in Limón include a Jamaican inspired seafood stew called "rondón," an Afro-Caribbean music style called "Calypso," and dancing styles from African tribes that inspires young Costa Ricans.

Music as a Form of Identity

Kombilesa Mí is a Colombian hip hop group from San Basilio de Palenque, who sought solidarity, resistance, struggle and preservation of their traditions as people of Palenque.

The sound of Kombilesa Mí is based on traditional rhythms such as the Sexteto, the Mapale, the bulleregue, and the chalusonga fusing them with Hip Hop creating new sonorities and contemporary musical expressions. The lyrics are in both Palenque Language and Spanish.

Can this form of identity inform SoCal Afro-Latinx?

Food as a Form of Identity

Desserts are my identity!

Everlinda Salgado Herrera is proud to be a Palenquera from San Basilio de Palenque. Like her mother and grandmother, she sells several sugary delights, such as cocadas, alegría, and caballitos.

Legend has it that, after abolition, residents named a delicious, coconut-laden treat “alegría” to honor the sweet taste of freedom.


Palenque In SoCal

There is an opportunity to use SCAG collected data to understand Afro-Latinx identity in SoCal.

Challenges and Discrimination

According to Pew Research Center, those who identify as Afro-Latinx are more likely to have lower household incomes and at the same time are less likely to have some college education compared to other Latinx.

"I have been told to stay out of the sun so that I don’t get darker (although I’m pretty light most of the time in NY, I can get very golden bronze). I’ve been told to straighten my hair to look more white and also to not wear bright lipstick because my lips are too big." -- An Afro-Latina conveyed how her racial features were monitored by her family members.

The current U.S. Census Bureau fails to record demographic data for Afro-Latinx due to their race/ethnic classification. There is no way for us to point out Afro-Latinx communities with absolute confidence.

What about considering both Black-Majority communities and Latino-Majority communities as possible Palenque (Afro-Latinx communities) in Southern California? Let's take a closer look.

Black-Majority Communities

Communities consist of more than 50% of Black population.

Latino-Majority Communities

Communities consist of more than 50% of Latino population

Possible Palenque

Communities consist of more than 50% of Black or Latino population. Most of these communities are located within Los Angeles County.

Median Household Income in Possible Palenque

The average median household income in possible Palenque was $46,972 in 2016, which was significantly lower than the median household income of the entire state of California ($67,739) or the U.S. ($57,617) in the same year.

Possible Palenque (Left)

SB 535 Disadvantaged Areas (Right)

“Disadvantaged communities” was designated by CalEPA for the purpose of SB 535. These have been designated using the CalEnviroScreen 3.0 screening methodology, which helps identify California communities that are disproportionately burdened by multiple sources of pollution.

Possible Palenque located within Disadvantaged Areas

89% of residents in possible Palenque are living within SB 535 Disadvantaged Areas, which places them at serious risk of cardiovascular and respiratory disease.

Healthy Place Index in Possible Palenque

Healthy Place Index (HPI) is composed of diverse non-medical economic, social, political and environmental factors that influence physical and cognitive function, behavior and disease. Higher the HPI better the living environment.

The average HPI across possible Palenque is only 23.68. Only three communities are ranked more than 75 among possible Palenque.

Food Access in Possible Palenque

Food access includes the percentage of the urban population residing less than 1/2 mile or the percentage of the rural population living less than 1 mile from a supermarket/large grocery store.

The average food accessibility across possible Palenque is 60%. Without good food accessibility, households would face the challenge of not getting enough food for an active, healthy life for all household members.

Park Access in Possible Palenque

Park accessibility includes a percentage of population living within a half-mile of a park, open space, or beach.

The average park accessibility across possible Palenque is 69%. Higher park accessibility can benefit health conditions for residents.

Tree Coverage in Possible Palenque

Tree coverage includes population-weighted percentage of census tract area with tree canopy coverage.

The average tree coverage across possible Palenque is only 4%, compared to California’s urban tree canopy covers 19% of the state's urban areas.

Where can the SCAG data help address social issues in SoCal?

Based on Census data, "Black" is African Americans without other race/ethnicity backgrounds.

"Latino" includes all Latinx of different races.

This grouping method created hardships with identifying Afro-Latinx identity in SoCal and in the entire U.S. In this case, considering both Black dominant communities and Latino dominant communities as possible Palenque can generate a more holistic analysis of environmental and social issues in SoCal.

SCAG data shows that economic, resident health, environmental conditions and resource accessibility in possible Palenque are not optimistic. Afro-Latinx is not just a ethno-racial term, but is a social group that needs support.

While Afro-Latinx identity is still being developed, extra implementation of economic development strategies, community empowerment plans, pollution prevention policies, and other programs should be a priority to improve the living conditions OF ALL.


The search for the Afro-Latinx identity will continue, because we are a richer community when we understand the value that all mix-identities individuals brings to the society.


Funding for this project was provided by CSUN 2020 Diversity and Equity Innovation Grant

Acknowledgement all of the following contributed to this project

Cover Image

Richard Cross, CSUN Bradly Center

Afro-Latinx Identity Formation

Hordge-Freeman E, Veras E. Out of the Shadows, into the Dark: Ethnoracial Dissonance and Identity Formation among Afro-Latinxs. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity. 2020;6(2):146-160. doi:10.1177/2332649219829784

Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade Data

Voyages: The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade Database

Spanish Hierarchically Racial System

Race Mixture in the History of Latin America, Magnus Mörner

Palenque Communities in Colombia

Ma Ngombe: guerreros y ganaderos en Palenque, Nina S. de Friedemann

Photos of San Basilio de Palenque

Richard Cross, CSUN Bradly Center

Afro-Latinx Music

Kombilesa Mi

Afro-Latinx Food

Great Big Story

Afro-Latinx Culture

Afro-Latino Travels with Kim Haas

Demographic Trends Data

Pew Research Center

Southern California GIS Data

Southern California Association of Governments (SCAG) GIS Open Data Portal

Acknowledgement

Professor Jose Luis Benavides

Professor Doug Kaback

Professor Joe Bautista

Marta Valier

Guillermo Marquez