Comfort Women Monuments: A Transnational Global Memoryscape
A Digital Humanities Resource for Students and Educators
About
Brief Context
Who are "comfort women"? The euphemistic term “comfort women” refers to the women and girls who were taken from their homes to be sexually exploited by the Japanese imperial military during WWII. Military “comfort stations” for the Japanese military existed from 1932-1945 across the Japanese empire, in Japan, colonial Korea, China, Taiwan, the Philippines, Indonesia, Singapore, Burma, and various Pacific islands.
Why monuments? The movement of bringing the historical existence of “comfort women” to light started in the 1980s as a transnational feminist undertaking initiated by scholars in South Korea, stretching over to Japan, the Philippines, and other Asian countries. Out of their continued activism came the erecting of memorials of “comfort women” in, first, Seoul, South Korea. While this resource displays just 10 monuments, 36 similar monuments now exist across the world in South Korea, the US, China, Australia, Canada, Germany, the Philippines, China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan.
What is a transnational global memoryscape? US scholars Kendall Phillips and Mitchell Reyes introduced the term, “global memoryscape,” to refer to the “intersection between memorial practices and global forces,” between “public memory and globalization.” A global memoryscape points out that public memory is not simply nation-bound, but global. This transnational network of “comfort women” monuments around the world exist as a decentralized network promoting memory of “comfort women” in their own unique national contexts. Taking this approach helps us ask, "How is history remembered differently between various publics and their public memories in their unique contexts? How is it all connected? How is it different?"
Navigating the Resource
This digital humanities resource is for students and educators of history, public memory, gender-based violence, human rights rhetoric, national and international affairs, grassroots activism, and political struggle.
This resource is designed for active learning. Explore what is shown and piece together what is unshown. Scroll through the slideshow , explore the map , and click through to links, particularly linking to "Notable Context," to piece together your own understanding of this transnational global memoryscape of comfort women memorials all around the world.
You may find it helpful to keep the following questions in mind as you navigate:
- Who put this monument together? What political forces (local and international) were they constrained by?
- Was there an opposition? Who was it? Why and what were they opposing? What larger geopolitical historical contexts can you piece together to form their motivations?
- What message is the monument communicating, both directly and indirectly?
- Where is this monument housed? Who had to sign off on this project to make this monument happen? How might these multiple stakeholders impact the message of the monument? How does geopolitical location contribute to the unique nature/nuances of this memory place?
- When was this monument built? Why then? What was happening at that time to allow for the success or failure of this monument?
Slideshow
The following slideshow shows details of 10 Statues of Peace that were created across a span of ten years, 2011-2020. Countries include: South Korea, USA, Canada, Australia, China, the Philippines, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Germany.
KOR - Seoul, South Korea
Statue of Peace 평화비
Who: Korean Council for Justice and Remembrance for the Issues of Military Sexual Slavery by Japan When: 2011 Where: Outside of the Japanese embassy in Seoul
Notable Context: NY Times (2011) "Statue Deepens Dispute Over Wartime Sexual Slavery" NY Times (2016) "‘Comfort Woman’ Statue Reinstated Near Japan Consulate in South Korea" CNN (2017) "Why this statue of a young girl caused a diplomatic incident"
USA - Glendale, California, USA
Who: Korean American Forum of California (KAFC) When: 2013 Where: Central Park near the Glendale Public Library
Notable Context: KQED (2014) "Cultural Battle Over 'Comfort Women' Statue Heads to Court" NPR (2013) "Statue Brings Friction Over WWII Comfort Women To California"
CA - Toronto, Canada
Who: Korean Canadian Association of Metropolitan Toronto When: 2015 Where: In front of the Korean Canadian Cultural Association Centre
Notable Context: Now Toronto (2020) "Hidden Toronto: Comfort Woman Statue" Ethno-Cultural Monuments in Canada (2015) "2015 Peace Monument" Statues for Equality "Comfort Women"
AUS - Sydney, Australia
Comfort Women Statue
Who: Peace Statue Establishing Committee When: 2016 Where: Unveiled in Korean Community Hall in Croydon Park, failed to erect in Strathfield , ultimately housed in Ashfield Uniting Church
Notable Context: ABC News (2016) "Comfort women statue unveiled in Sydney despite ongoing tensions" BBC (2016) "The big row over a small Australian statue" Reuters (2016) "Race complaint lodged over 'comfort women' statue in Australian church"
Related Organizations: Opposing : Australia-Japan Community Network made complaint to Australia's Human Rights Commission , threatened legal action against church based on Racial Discrimination Act
CN - Shanghai, China
Comfort Women Statue *depicting a Korean girl and a Chinese girl
Who: Shanghai Normal University, with donations by South Korean citizens of Hwaseong (city south of Seoul) , unveiling ceremony conducted by International Committee for Joint Nomination to UNESCO International Memory of the World When: 2016 Where: Shanghai Normal University
Notable Context: China.org (2007) "Shanghai Opens Comfort Women Archives" Dong-a Ilbo (2016) "Comfort women statues set up for the first time in China" Yonhap News Agency (2016) "'Comfort women' statues erected in China"
PH - Manila, Philippines
Filipina Comfort Women Statue *depicts a Filipina woman
Who: Tulay Foundation, a Chinese-Filipino organization, with an accompanying memorial marker provided by the National Historical Commission of the Philippines When: 2017, dismantled in 2018 by national government, stolen in 2019 from sculptor Where: Baywalk, Roxas Boulevard, a popular waterfront promenade
Notable Context: Inquirer.net (2017) "‘Comfort woman’ statue not an insult vs Japan’" Inquirer.net (2018) "Artist hurting over banished ‘Comfort Woman’ statue" South China Morning Post (2021) "‘Comfort women’ statue missing in the Philippines as Japan’s wartime legacy under focus"
Related Organizations Lila Pilipina Task Force on Filipina Comfort Women (TFFCW)
USA - San Francisco, California, USA
Column of Strength *depicts a Korean girl, a Filipina girl, and a Chinese girl, and
Who: Comfort Women Justice Coalition When: 2017 Where: Saint Mary's Square, between Chinatown and the Financial District in San Francisco
Notable Context: NPR (2018) "Osaka, Japan, Ends Ties With San Francisco In Protest Of 'Comfort Women' Statue" NY Times (2018) "‘It Is Not Coming Down’: San Francisco Defends ‘Comfort Women’ Statue as Japan Protests" NBC (2019) "Who are the 'comfort women,' and why are U.S.-based memorials for them controversial?"
Photo source: Author
HK - Hong Kong
Comfort Women Peace Statue *depicts a Korean woman and a Chinese woman
Who: Action Committee for Defending the Diaoyu Islands, a Hong Kong-based activist group that asserts China's sovereignty over the Diaoyu Islands, which are disputed between China, Japan, and Taiwan When: 2017, on the 80th anniversary of the Sino-Japanese War to commemorate those who worked in the Japanese military's wartime brothels , removed in 2021 by creators Where: Near Japan's Consulate in Hong Kong
Notable Context: South China Morning Post (2017) "Old war wounds opened up by Hong Kong statues of ‘comfort women’" AP (2017) "No plans to remove ‘comfort women’ statues in Hong Kong" The Standard (2017) "Activists say Japanese right-wingers threatened them over comfort women statues" Kyodo News (2021) "Statues of "comfort women" near Japan consulate in Hong Kong removed"
TW - Tainan, Taiwan
Comfort Women Statue *depicts a Taiwanese woman
Who: Tainan Association for Comfort Women’s Rights, led by former Kuomintang (KMT, or the Chinese Nationalist Party) affiliate When: 2018 on International Comfort Women Day, August 14 Where: In the city centre, beside the KMT's Tainan chapter office, KMT property
Notable Context: Smithsonian Magazine (2018) "Taiwan Unveils Its First Statue Honoring ‘Comfort Women’" Kyodo News (2018) "1st "comfort women" statue installed in Taiwan" Buzzfeed (2018) "A Japanese Man Appeared To Kick A Statue Dedicated To "Comfort Women" In Taiwan And People Are Pissed" South China Morning Post (2018) "Japanese nationalist group apologises for member who kicked Taiwan comfort woman statue" BBC (2023) "'Comfort women': Last known Taiwanese survivor dies at 92"
Related Organizations: Taipei Women’s Rescue Foundation, Taipei Times (2023) "‘Comfort women’ memorials held" Ama Museum ( closed in 2020 ), Global Taiwan Institute (2021) "The Struggle Over “Comfort Women” in Taiwan: Historical Memory and Lack of Consensus"
GER - Berlin, Germany
Who: AG "Comfort Women" (An Action Group in the Korea Association" When: 2020 Where: Near transit station U Birkenstraße in Berlin, on Bremer Street
Notable Context: Geschichtedergegenwart (2020) "Contested Memory. The ‘Comfort Women’ Statue in Berlin and Dealing with Sexual Violence in War" The Nation (2022) "The Fight Over Berlin’s Comfort Woman Statue" Kyodo News (2022) "Japan PM asked German leader to help remove "comfort women" statue" Japan Forward (2022) "Comfort Women Issue: A New Opportunity for Berlin's 'Statue of Peace'?" The Asia Pacific Journal (2022) "The Statue of Peace in Berlin: How the Nationalist Reading of Japan’s Wartime “Comfort Women” Backfired
Interactive Map
Click through each of the ten locations to examine where each monument is located and its surrounding context.
Discussion Questions
- Where is the statue located, and what significance might that contribute to the message of the monument? E.g. In a large metropolitan city, in front of an embassy, near the waterfront, in a church, on land owned by a political party or office, etc?
- What does location say about what relationships needed to be navigated to erect the monument? What political tensions might there be based on where it is housed?
Additional Resources
Discussion Questions
- What observations do you find yourself drawing as you read all of these different sites in tandem?
- How might those observations have differed if this resource had displayed a different assortment of examples? e.g. 10 statues all in South Korea, more statues from the US, etc...
- What might a transnational network of similar statues say about public memory?
- ...
Organizations
Contact the creator here: jinrebekahchoi@gmail.com